Philosophy Wars

Music Industry Hell: Where is the Rebellion?


the philosphy wars

s menu - click a section what's new at www.eadon.com philosophy movie reviews cartoons - garden of eadon cartoons bible satire pics, images and poems about nun whipping bishops etc :) philosophy wars discussions and battles on religion and many other maddening topics Jim on diets, daft names and other musings Feng Shui Hippo's zodiac - a spoof of astrology and feng shui here is info about me, jim eadon and more read my novel madpole - the maddest but truest philosopher on this planet coincidences of readers etc read and sign my guestbook links s
body frame image body frame image
s

Typical quote: "Now the record industry is basically 4 colossal corporations. This is not healthy. They are not nurturing talent, but investing in boy and girl bands." - eadon-com

Below is a transcript of channel 103 chat. Channel 103 is a place where religion is discussed, (atheists battle the Christians). (I am eadon-com by the way.)

eadon-com: We expect that our relatives should be normal, but this is a flawed and highly over-optimistic expectation. It is more realistic to expect that our relatives are totally bananas and any trace of sanity is but a freaky mutation of the genetic code

anon: I call my father up for xmas and he tells me he doesn't want to see anyone this year and is rambling about some young girl who took all his money. I just returned his xmas presents, My GF was shocked by his lunacy and old-heartedness. She had only heard stories until then....

anon: Bitter old man who can't accept he's not 25 anymore and wasted his whole life doing nothing. Venting is good right?

anon: Funny thing is if you have a nutty parent nothing shocks you but your significant other is always outraged and telling you how your family is from mars or something....

eadon-com: Since when is that anything new???

catdoc: "If you have a nutty parent" ....? I don't know if I've ever met anyone who didn't.

eadon-com: The inlaws are universally outrageous people to all

anon: My GF is constantly telling me how I take my mothers side JUST BY STAYING OUT OF IT ALL AND SAYING NOTHING. How does that work? I'm truly puzzled...

eadon-com: As I get older I find that pretension and eccentricity become more and more acceptable, even enjoyable, and certainly I am less outraged by it. In fact, as I get older, as madpole says too, normal people are the people who seem most abhorrent and weird

Isolani: O anon your girlfriend is putting you in the position of responsibility for her own emotions. Sounds like.

eadon-com: A beautiful realisation strikes me

eadon-com: That it is the parents who rebel against their children and not vice versa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Christ! This is utterly true and I have only just realised it

Isolani: funny eadon. Unless you're serious. Then I pause to cogitate deeply.

eadon-com: The children are the conformists and the parents are the rebellions, the eccentrics the weirdoes! I bet that, if not universal, this happens. A LOT.

Dudge: I don't get it, eadon.

anon: The funny thing is Isolani, that I think my girlfriend over-reacts over my mother but of course I don't tell her that. That would be the start of months of living down that statement.

eadon-com: Nor did I until today Dudge

Isolani: This is pot. This is an egg. This is a frying pan. And this is eadon on pot.

Isolani: Any questions?

Dudge: Sure. Why do you dismiss eadon's statements out of hand so quickly?

eadon-com: Come come, Anon, the mother of the child in a tug of war over her son's girlfriend? Surely not :)

Madpole: I remember being so cleverly cruel to my sister that I convinced her that she has a button at the back and if I push it she will cry. I used to do it all the time - push the button. She would cry and beg me to push the button back to stop it. We (or rather she) went through hell - so we can be really supportive towards each other now

Isolani: Who are you addressing Dudge?

Dudge: You, Isolani :)

Isolani: Oh, for silliness sake Dudge. You can bet on that.

Dudge: eadon's statement seemed kinda silly too. I was hoping he'd explain it a bit better. (eadon?)

eadon-com: Thanks Dudge :)

eadon-com: Well I will try.

Isolani: Go eadon, show proofs, statistics, site books about this theory of yours :)

eadon-com: Teenagers always conform to what ever fashions teenagers conform too. Teenagers try to cohere with the fashions that commerce and style magazines etc dictate to be trendy...

Isolani: Following eadon now...

eadon-com: Parents on the other hand have already been through that conformist phase and are now free to find themselves, to discover their own personalities and there comes the revelation:

Isolani: That they're overweight and boring?

eadon-com: For the first time the parents are able to be themselves, to express their inner spirit, if you will, without the pressures of peer approval, so what happens?

anon: eadon, my mother still wears grateful dead t-shirts and my stepfather still smokes weed...explain that in your little theory:)

Dudge: I think the parents are generally conformist too, eadon, just conforming to something else.

eadon-com: The parents be themselves, ie, they are not trendy and they do not seek approval, they do not even seek to be liked by their surrounding humans....

Dudge: Sure they do.

eadon-com: Indeed they are free to be themselves, which would be to say that they become INDIVIDUALS. This would be most disconcerting to the conformist offspring, who immediately label their parents as weird and nuts...

eadon-com: Yet, and here is the twist...

Dudge: eadon, I think most parents are conformist also, but conformist to the groups they spend time in instead of the teens conforming to the groups they spend time in...

Isolani: eadon I think you're missing the mark. Nice try though.

Dudge: Many parents and youth are "conformist," but conformist to different things. Some are not.

eadon-com: The parents don't care what their kids (or anyone else for that matter) thinks of them anymore. The parents literally rebel. This juxtaposition against the be-cool-like-everyone-else conformist attitude of their kids is my evidence for the fact that it is the parents that rebel against their children and NOT vice versa

Dudge: [quotes eadon]

eadon-com: "The parents don't care what their kids (or anyone else for that matter) thinks of them anymore." <-- I disagree.

eadon-com: Why Dudge?

Dudge: eadon, perhaps youth "as a group" conform to a standard which is rebelling against the standard set by the older generation.

Isolani: Yeah, Dudge is right as usual. Of course parents take care of their social standing and are aware of what their peers may think of them. Why mow a lawn then?

Madpole: I tell You what parents do for eadon will do the same for you - parents blame their children for who they are (parents that is)

Dudge: Because I think parents also conform, eadon.

eadon-com: Now I am not saying that my theory is universal

Isolani: I aver that every single younger generation "rebels" in similar fashion to it's removed twin, from it's second or third generation. Give me an ear.

eadon-com: But what I do say is that on average my theory does prove that ON AVERAGE parents rebel against their children more then their children rebel

Madpole: Parents are the one's spirit worse enemy - I would have died long time ago if it was not for my parents - what an absolutely stupid statement to make - but it is true at the same time

Dudge: eadon, I don't think so... Perhaps the children do not rebel *as individuals*, but the standard they conform to (they are conformist, like the parents) is a rebellion against the standard the parents conform to. I know I said that before, eadon, but maybe you didn't catch it the first time.

Isolani: Turgenev. In one of Turngenev one comes upon the character of a young man who has an ear ring and long hair and is fashionably liberal. Is that not somewhat akin to this day? That was 1880.

anon: It's was always weird having my friends come over and look through my parents CD collection going damn your parents are cool..... "yea but you don't have to live with them", I'd say

eadon-com: Well Isolani I would argue that the younger generation is more interested in conforming with the fashion of the day than rebelling. Now the fashion of the day might be a rebellious one, and this certainly was true, but these days the fashions are dictated by huge corporations run by the older generations.

Dudge: anon, our parents' generation did have better music than ours... ;(

Madpole: I know a girl who had a cancer..... parents were her worst enemy - not cancer - they nearly killed her - luckily she had enough courage to overcome it

eadon-com: true Dudge

Isolani: anon, I know some people your parents' age with good music and they aren't cool either. I'd hate to extrapolate ... One screwy generation?

eadon-com: pop today is another example of the non-rebellion of today's kids. They are force-fed manufactured pop by manufactured bands by senior generations in the name of recouping their bestowed pocket money

Dudge: the beatles, the kinks...all their generation, anon, not ours :(

Madpole: Parents hate when their children die before them - and that just proves that they are not tuned to religion - they do not believe in God - age is not important when it comes to death .. but they hate THEMSELVES blah blah blah..

Dudge: Sure, eadon, in general. Parents do the same thing, but with different standards that they are conforming to.

anon: True story...I stole my step-fathers stash once and smoked up and got really sick....there was def. something else in that crap....what a mockery....having my stepfather laughing over me going "good stuff huh lolol"....sheesh,

eadon-com: I saw a teenage chick justifying commercial sponsorship of a rock concert [the Glastonbury festival in England] on television, not realising how she was being exploited. That is today's kids for you.

Dudge: She may be a good actor, eadon, and not care if she's being "exploited" :)

eadon-com: sure Dudge, but that is even worse

Dudge: "Today's kids"? eadon, was your generation any different?

eadon-com: Yup

eadon-com: Less commercial in my day. (and we had better music (80's) lol)

Dudge: Adults have been complaining about "today's youth" throughout history.

Isolani: Right Dudge.

anon: Right Dudge.

Dudge: stick to 60's and 70's eadon, and you'll do a bit better on that scale :)

eadon-com: yes Dudge, but this is the first time that the kids have been slave to commercial corporations force-feeding them their music and clothes

Isolani: I recall when the 80's came around feeling lost in the radio wasteland.

Dudge: Sure, but eadon, that's not the youth themselves being commercial... it's the times. Adults today are just as drawn into the commercial stuff!

eadon-com: The kids have no wish to rebel against the commercial organisations, this amazes me. The record industry now is corporate, the kids are given crap music by "executives"

Dudge: Sure, some are. But the fact that that happens is not due to *anything* about the kids themselves. It's the times. As I said, adults *today* are fed just as much commercial crap as kids *today*.

anon: Napster

Isolani: Napster is cool. Napster is indeed a big hope! Hopefully the kids will use mp3 to wrest control back from the music industry. Napster is their one big hope

Dudge: eadon, ya think the music industry immediately was allowed to take control as soon as the people in this generation were born? no... It was a process. A process that was well under way before anyone in that generation was born.

HammondEggs: It started, at latest, in the mid seventies. Anybody heard of Disco? That was pure corporate garbage.

eadon-com: Well I am saying that it happened gradually, but now the record industry is basically 4 colossal corporations. This is not healthy. They are not nurturing talent, but investing in boy and girl bands. These days things have gone to extremes

Dudge: Fine, eadon.

HammondEggs: I don't see the difference, eadon.

Dudge: But I was commenting on your original point. The commercialisation of today's youth has nothing to do with the youth themselves (it's happening to today's adults too!), but rather to do with factors outside of them.

eadon-com: I, the adult, am more outraged about the music industry than the teenagers, HammondEggs and Dudge!!!!!!!!!!!!!! See my point about the parents rebelling more than the kids!!!!!!!

Dudge: eadon, no.

eadon-com: The kids have all been brainwashed by the record industry hype and advertising

HammondEggs: eadon, just because you yell more doesn't mean you are more outraged.

Dudge: That really has nothing to do with it at all. You know I don't listen to the pop garbage they give us (and you).

Dudge: exactly, HammondEggs :)

eadon-com: Well I don't hear HammondEggs and Dudge being indignant at the dire state of the music industry

Dudge: eadon, it may not be you as an individual, but you're generation is just as "brainwashed" and brainwashed in the exact same manner!

eadon-com: You guys haven't tasted better. If you feed people banal and bland crap they will, over time, come to like it

anon: Sheesh, if they didn't go commercial in the 80's first then I don't know when they did.

Dudge: eadon, quit the condescending BS. You know very well we've tasted better.

HammondEggs: eadon, I am quite weary of the meager selection. However, I make do by being careful about my purchases, and not just accepting anything the radio offers me. I support Napster wholeheartedly, not because I agree with it, but because I want to see the record industry crumble.

Dudge: I just got finished saying I listen to music from your time more, didn't I?

eadon-com: Obviously Dudge you might say that, but it is me, not you, who is outraged by the way music has been commercialised

Dudge: eadon, I don't like it any more than you do... The only difference is I'm not here shouting my silly theories about it and being condescending. This is below you, eadon. You're barely reading anything I say.

Isolani: I love this channel.

anon: amen Isolani

Dudge: You say we "haven't tasted better" when you KNOW (or would know if you paid attention to what I was saying) that I don't like modern pop any more than you do!

Madpole: at this time of the night Dudge, You can hardly blame eadon for that

Dudge: I very well can blame him for it. ;)

HammondEggs: eadon's probably sleepy. Let him rant if he likes.

eadon-com: well Dudge listen to yourself. You don't like modern music any more than I do! Think about it. That is very sad

Dudge: eadon, I was in this [chat] channel just the other day complaining about modern Carlos Santana. I like his older stuff, but the newer (commercialized?) stuff is nowhere near as good.

Dudge: I agree with you, almost completely, as far as the music is concerned.

HammondEggs: Anybody that old is bound to be worse, Dudge.

eadon-com: Exactly! Dudge unwittingly proved eadon's point!!! Modern rubbish is force-fed to the kids. The kids resort to their parent's music.

Dudge: What is very sad? The state of modern music?

Dudge: It ain't that, HammondEggs.

Isolani: Modern eadon?

Dudge: I didn't unwittingly prove shit, eadon.

eadon-com: I am the only one who is saying that this is wrong, the modern kids should have better pop than their parents!!!

HammondEggs: Sure it is. Look at what happened to the Rolling Stones after 20 years of producing music.

Dudge: I was using that as an example of how I agree with you. eadon, how many times have I said I DON'T LIKE IT EITHER?

eadon-com: There IS very good modern music, but it is virtually all underground.

Dudge: Just because I'm not mindlessly ranting about it, eadon, doesn't mean that I find it any less wrong than you.

eadon-com: Great! then we agree!

Isolani: Poor Dudge he's always misunderstood here. Dudge, when you agree (which is rarely) you still get flak.

HammondEggs: There is a lot more music out today than there was twenty years ago. Although there is a whole lot of garbage, there is also plenty of music worth listening to. You just sometimes need to look more carefully than in the past. You can't trust radio to help you, either.

eadon-com: Dudge disagrees with eadon and then comes round to eadon's way of thinking :)

Dudge: Isolani, I get "flak" because eadon is on his rant giving flak to anyone in my generation.

Dudge: Comes around?! eadon, no.

Dudge: Isolani, eadon has to claim bad things about my generation, so he tells HammondEggs and I that we haven't tasted anything better than modern pop. Condescending bullshit.

Isolani: For eadon it's win or lose, not how you play the game. It's not understanding that eadon wants, some middle way, but full throttle kill the other guy?

Dudge: eadon, adults today are "taken in" by the commercialization too. You think kids are responsible for all the evils of the music industry? No.

anon: I only bought one modern album this year and that was the red hot chilli peppers. But, even they are becoming an old band .....when I was 16 they were really hip and underground......

Isolani: SUV's, that's being taken in by commercialism. Who the hell needs one of those things for commuting?

eadon-com: Oh come come Isolani! I merely stated my position. The kids were indignant and stated I was wrong. I merely stuck to my guns and they realised that I was right all along and agreed with me :)

Dudge: It may not be you that is "brainwashed" by the pop garbage, but many other adults are.

HammondEggs: I blame kids for Getty Lee releasing an album which got good reviews. That is inconceivable.

Dudge: Oh my God. eadon, I don't care if you're serious or not, but this is REALLY way too much.

eadon-com: Dudge CANT HANDLE the TRUTH

anon: lol

anon: This is too fun to watch...

HammondEggs: Quoting popular garbage now, are we?

eadon-com: It is all up there in black and white Dudge. Cut and paste the tells, study them, and learn

Dudge: eadon, scroll up. And copy ANY tell of mine that I've now changed my mind about.

HammondEggs: Dudge, who cares if eadon is wrong?

Dudge: HammondEggs, call it petty if you want, but I wasn't gonna let eadon go on with condescending BS without a "challenge."

HammondEggs: It is petty.

anon: Cmon, think of the 80's and Debbie Gibson, they have been ramming this crap down our throats for awhile now...

HammondEggs: Of course, anon. You can go before Disco, even. Take a gander at Herman's Hermits. They were the pop garbage in the days of the Beatles.

HughJass: Quit pulling punches. Everyone knows it's the bad taste of teenagers that's responsible for all the crap.

DeaconNihilo: you want kids to take a more hostile attitude to the world as we know it eadon?

eadon-com: Well, what I was saying was DeaconNihilo, is that the parents these days are more rebellious than the children
[eadon hears cries emerging from the bedroom. One of the baby twins demands to be fed]


eadon-com: baby cries :( baby rebels [exits to feed the baby and hence quench the sore decibels of yearning]



add a talkback
Please add your comment to this page


sssss
From: BromethiusSubject:2002-08-25 12:58:47
s
From: DaizySubject:2002-11-03 15:15:50
s
From: markSubject:2003-06-07 23:54:31
s
help: how to add your comment

Page hits: 3817



body frame image body frame image
s


www.eadon.com home sweet home contents: more stuff next page


www.eadon.com