movies section

Star wars Episode One:
The Phantom Menace


How thoughtful of the movie studios to give away the plot in the trailer

s menu - click a section what's new at www.eadon.com philosophy movie reviews cartoons - garden of eadon cartoons bible satire pics, images and poems about nun whipping bishops etc :) philosophy wars discussions and battles on religion and many other maddening topics Jim on diets, daft names and other musings Feng Shui Hippo's zodiac - a spoof of astrology and feng shui here is info about me, jim eadon and more read my novel madpole - the maddest but truest philosopher on this planet coincidences of readers etc read and sign my guestbook links s
body frame image body frame image
s



Star wars: The Phantom Menace
Directed by George Lucas




Star Wars: The Phantom Menace is the first Star Wars movie in several millennia. For any admirable person who doesn't know, The Phantom Menace is a sci-fi action movie about a bunch of good guys - The Jedi vs. the a bunch of bad guys -The Sith - in a wrangle over the a galactic Empire. A young kid Anakin (who will grow up to be Darth Vader, well, it beats being a lawyer) is conscripted by the Jedi to fight the "Dark Side".

The first thing to note about The Phantom Menace is the shitload of computer graphics. Behold the incessant, - and not unlovely - CGI. To take just one example, during the pod race, those engines did not just blow up in a cheap fireball, they disintegrated, with the internal components rendered as well as the outer casings. The race itself looked astoundingly real. Yet of the stadium, aliens, pods and landscape, practically the only real thing was the sky. The Phantom Menace is a computer game without the interactivity. And surprise surprise! There's a spin-off computer game.

The Phantom Menace looks for all the world like a two-hour trailer for the next two films in the series. And yet it still manages to be good in a superficial way. But naturally it was bound to incur the wrath of the purist geeks. Fanboys were expecting brilliance for some reason. Lucas himself actually said that many fans would enjoy queuing up more than watching the film. And the fanboys got Jar Jar Binks! Haha! Serves them right.

Then there is the over-cute child Anakin Skywalker: it's weird seeing the way everyone calls the future murderous, neck-crushing, supreme bad egg Darth Vader "Annie"! Imagine the bullying he endured at school. No wonder he turns to the Dark Side. I am willing to wager Darth Maul never got called a girl's name - or if he did then his suicidal tormentor met with a shockingly sticky end.

But if a film's going to be deeply flawed then let it be deeply flawed like The Phantom Menace! Nearly every scene's lease is too brief. With the exceptions of the ridiculous Binks, the tedious muppet Yoda and the assorted women and children (unfortunately in this type of movie cute things are just not as interesting as warriors and monsters) all the characters are impressive. Darth Maul's glare is so evil and his swordsmanship is so dangerous that it's an absolute crime he gets a now-you-see-me-now-you-don't part. Qui-Gon Jinn is your quiet type, unsensational but good fun with a light sabre. Kenobi ditto. Palpatine is delectably cunning and slippery. Sebulba is a joyfully nasty piece of work. And Watto! Watto is just sleazy shiftiness rendered glorious.

To have so many groovy characters come and go while the buffoon Ja Ja Binks hogs the screen is enough to drive you insane. But... even when crippled with Ja Ja, Star Wars pisses on touchy feely Star Trek's cornflakes.

**** Spoiler sentence:

Incidentally, the fight ending has been cut and pasted right out of "Blind Fury".

**** End Spoiler



Jim's preferred ending: Jar Jar Binks and Yoda are locked up in a different galaxy even further-further away, where they can do no more harm.

Rating: 4/5
score


Do you think this movie is any good?

Click on one of the buttons below

12 3456789 10
Ghastly OK Fantastic
s View Results


Add your comment to this page

add a talkback

sssss
From: sinahSubject:2001-12-12 10:11:13
s
From: hung-pieceSubject:2002-01-11 18:41:34
s
From: True CriticSubject:2002-06-05 00:29:50
s
From: meSubject:2005-12-09 18:22:05
s
help: how to add your comment

Page hits: 6633



Attack of the Clones review



body frame image body frame image
s


www.eadon.com home sweet home contents: more stuff Next uninformed movie review


www.eadon.com