talkback:
star wars - revenge of the sith

Add your comment

From:	Mark Radburn	2005-08-30 10:45:25
Subject:	The Worstest Star Wars movie ever!
Comment:	This films sucks, it has a bad storyline and bad acting and is nowhere as good as the previous 2. Here's another reason why I hate his gay movie it kicked Jurassic Park off the Top-10 Box Office list. Star Wars Revenge Of The Sith does not deserve to be in the Top-10 Box Office List, I mean like come on Jurassic Park is more popular than crappy Star Wars. I never liked the Star Wars trilogy. And the actors sucked, George Lucas your an asshole for making this movie. With me and the Jurassic Park movies togther we can take over the Star Wars Movies any day. Don't watch this crap movie I repeat do not watch Star Wars Revenge Of The Sith.
From:	Matt Sutton	2005-11-09 23:21:28
Subject:	Rubbish Film
Comment:	Star Wars 3 sucked and it was complete crap, the special effects weren't as good as the previous star wars movies and the storyline sucked and it didn't make any sense why waste money on a crappy film like this. I wish Universal Studios would hurry up on the upcoming Jurassic Park 4 that's going to be releashed in theaters in 2006 because it's 10 times more entertaining than this crap.
From:	Steven Brady	2005-11-11 07:01:55
Subject:	A Crap Movie
Comment:	Thumbs Down. Star Wars: Revenge Of The Sith sucked and it's really bad. The starting was stupid I mean come on make a better starting and the ending sucked. Star Wars 3 sucked no I'm not kidding don't watch this crappy film that George Lucas made.
From:	jake	2006-01-10 00:33:29
Subject:	more bad feelings 1
Comment:	Following on from the filmic tragedy that was episode 2, there is episode 3 The local rags reviewer said that 'all fans questions are answered' Only if the questions include, can natalie portman act or can lucas do something coherent with her - No and can Lucas destroy the childhoods of millions by killing the dream - Yes First and most importantly I doubt over obiwans goodness after leaving his opponent in writhing agony on the floor without finishing him or or saving him. If he'ld sliced his legs off and then lost anakin under a ledge so it had looked like he'ld died, fair enough but just walking away to let him die, is pure evil. Ian mcdiarmid looking angry is like most people trying to shift a particularly recalcitrant stool. Why do all the battledroids, stamped out of an assembly line like fridges all talk like vietnam vets. And they panic, did no-one in QA think to check whether, when fired on, they run around like headless chickens. On MSN there was a list of 10 questions which must be answered by the film, can't remember all of them but of the main ones midichlorians, this star trek explanation for the force really grated. Lucas said that it'ld be explained but no. From a mystical kinda hippie thing it's gone to a thing controlled by parasites. Way to go George, the Jedi are full of tapeworms Anakin is asked to sit on the council but is not granted the rank of master, and it's never been heard of for a knight to sit on the council...apart from ki adi mundi, the guy with the tall head and white facial fuzz who was a knight on the council. As mentioned in several places in continuity.
From:	jake	2006-01-10 00:33:56
Subject:	more bad feelings 2
Comment:	There has always been a debate in starwars circles about what is cannon, i.e. the gospel. Some insist it's just the films and others that it goes all the way out to everything with starwars on the label. While most viewers will not have read any of the books, comics, etc. someone at lucasarts has, the blue twilek jedi and general vos are both from the comics for example. Lucas ignoring his own continuity is going to annoy the fans who wanted the films in the first place How come C3P0 and R2D2 don't remember what happened in ep1-3? Lucas said that they wouldn't get a mindwipe. He...lies... hey presto 3P0 gets a mindwipe, but hold on...R2 doesn't and he's the brains of the outfit. You think he wouldn't tell 3P0 everything when he came back from mindwipe Oh and how come 3P0 is the same obnoxious droid in the originals if he's been wiped. Is being a git inbuilt in the design Seeing the dead. How come in the originals obiwan and yodas body disappear but in ep1 quigonn and the other jedis don't. no explanation given whatsoever. But yoda does tell obiwan at the end he'll teach him how to commune with the dead through the force. How this helps luke see obiwan in ESB when he hasn't learnt it...who knows. Which leads me onto the last 5 minutes. It's painful. It's the 'wrap up all the loose ends I couldn't be bothered to sort out in due time' part. Mindwipe, check. Dead, check. dead padme, check. and on and on, flashing by.
From:	jake	2006-01-10 00:34:02
Subject:	more bad feelings 3
Comment:	For all lucas's talk of organic beating mechanical, a theme through all the films, why must he use so much tech in making the films. Computers graphics should enhance not be a the point of the setting. Anakin killed all the jedi, younglings and what not to protect padme during childbirth only to kill her himself, I saw the irony, I just didn't care by that point. The screamed 'Noooooooooo' at the end reminded me of the girl at the end of Scary Movie more than the heart rending scream of despair it should have been. And the death star took what 20 years to build, but the second death star (bigger, better, more fzap for your erg) took only 3 or 4. They really honed those production techniques. And remember if you think ewoks can't beat stormtroopers, go and stand outside with a crash helmet on and I'll throw rocks at you. Then you will know the power of the ewok. 3rd rule of the universe, anything can be broken if hit with a large enough rock. Anyway, anyone who has seen spaced series 2 knows what's happening to my star wars stuff this weekend. Thanks George for curing me of my love of Star Wars my girlfriend, family and friends thank you.