Choose God Or Freewill

Say, for arguments sake, an All-powerful God exists. He must be timeless because He created time. An All-powerful God will have completely created all our actions and thoughts at the Moment of Creation before we were born! If our actions were decided before we were born, then we have no Freewill. (Even if we think we have.)

Freewill and All-powerful Deities are mutually exclusive. If you believe in an all-powerful deity then you must forfeit Freewill. On the bright side, if you have no freewill then at least you can sin without conscience.

If there is an All-powerful God then it must follow that all acts of evil such as murder, rape and torture were deliberately created by God Himself. Oh dear!

In conclusion, you cannot choose to have your cake and choose to eat it.

I go deeper into this subject here.

Mad Pole (and me again) on Freewill

Do you think that there can be both an All-Powerful God AND freewill? Click on one of the buttons below

1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10

No

Maybe

Yes

View Results

Add your comment to this page

From:	Xerculees	Subject:	Freewill	2001-01-08 12:22:33
From:	james Plaskett	Subject:	Free will	2001-02-09 09:52:34
From:	Reader	Subject:	Coincidences....	2001-02-09 18:21:32
From:	Oliver Traldi	Subject:	Free will	2001-04-11 19:17:05
From:	SpecialKasadilla	Subject:	sadness...	2002-10-18 21:26:23
From:	maria	Subject:	0	2002-10-28 19:36:35
From:	Topher	Subject:	free will	2003-04-16 21:00:25
From:	anti-theist	Subject:	religous psychosis	2003-06-23 20:04:08
From:	d.yager	Subject:	responce	2003-07-20 00:15:01
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	Reconciling God and Freewill	2003-08-13 16:00:46
From:	cosmicstargoat	Subject:	God and Free Will-dogs of diogenes	2003-08-18 19:40:59
From:	noemail@noemail.com	Subject:	Freewill	2003-10-11 16:29:03
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	Reply to Cosmic Star Goat	2003-11-20 20:13:16
From:	cosmicstargoat	Subject:	free will	2003-11-21 06:24:19
From:	Eadon (Author of the article)	Subject:	Freewill is a myth 1	2003-11-21 08:37:30
From:	Eadon	Subject:	Freewill is a myth 2	2003-11-21 08:38:35
From:	Eadon	Subject:	Freewill is a myth 3	2003-11-21 08:39:35
From:	Eadon	Subject:	Freewill is a myth 4	2003-11-21 09:12:14
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	Eternal and Atemporal	2003-12-24 23:22:38
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	Does freewill exist at all	2003-12-24 23:38:19
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	No freewill anyway	2003-12-24 23:50:03
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	Paradox?	2003-12-24 23:59:37
From:	DogsOfDiogenes	Subject:	What's the point again?	2003-12-25 00:13:45
From:	ron	Subject:	god?	2005-01-15 13:52:43
From:	C.S. Lewis	Subject:	Mere Christianity	2007-11-14 00:05:03

View the comments

help: how to add your comment

Page hits: 6750